Pros And Cons Of Living In Ave Maria Florida

Ave Maria, Florida, is a master-planned community located in Collier County. Founded in 2005, this town is known for its strong Catholic identity, picturesque surroundings, and modern amenities. It was developed around Ave Maria University and the Ave Maria Oratory, with a vision of creating a close-knit, faith-based community. As with any location, living in Ave Maria has its own set of advantages and challenges. This article aims to provide a comprehensive analysis of the pros and cons of living in Ave Maria, Florida, to help potential residents make an informed decision.

Pros of Living in Ave Maria, Florida

1. Strong Sense of Community

One of the most significant benefits of living in Ave Maria is the strong sense of community. The town was designed to foster a close-knit, family-oriented environment, with numerous community events, activities, and social gatherings. This sense of belonging can be particularly appealing for families and individuals seeking a supportive and engaging atmosphere.

2. Beautiful and Well-Planned Environment

Ave Maria is a beautifully designed town with well-maintained streets, parks, and public spaces. The community features a variety of architectural styles, lush landscaping, and scenic views, creating an aesthetically pleasing environment. The town’s master-planned layout ensures that amenities and services are easily accessible to residents.

3. Faith-Based Community

Ave Maria has a strong Catholic identity, which can be a significant draw for individuals and families seeking a faith-based community. The town is home to Ave Maria University, a Catholic liberal arts college, and the impressive Ave Maria Oratory, a focal point for religious activities and gatherings. This faith-centered environment can provide spiritual fulfillment and a sense of shared values.

4. Modern Amenities and Facilities

Despite its relatively recent establishment, Ave Maria boasts a wide range of modern amenities and facilities. The town includes shopping centers, restaurants, healthcare services, and recreational facilities, ensuring that residents have convenient access to essential services and entertainment options. The presence of state-of-the-art sports facilities, golf courses, and community centers enhances the quality of life for residents.

5. Education Opportunities

Ave Maria offers excellent educational opportunities for residents, from primary to higher education. In addition to Ave Maria University, the town is served by several public and private schools, providing quality education options for families with children. The focus on education and intellectual growth is a key feature of the community.

6. Low Crime Rate

Ave Maria is known for its low crime rate, contributing to a sense of safety and security for residents. The town’s family-friendly environment and strong community ties help maintain a peaceful and secure living atmosphere, making it an attractive option for families and retirees.

7. Outdoor Activities and Recreation

The town’s location in Southwest Florida offers numerous opportunities for outdoor activities and recreation. Residents can enjoy biking, hiking, and bird-watching in nearby nature preserves and parks. The town’s well-maintained parks and recreational facilities also provide ample opportunities for sports, fitness, and leisure activities.

8. Warm Climate

Ave Maria enjoys a warm, subtropical climate with mild winters and hot summers. The abundant sunshine throughout the year makes it an ideal location for outdoor enthusiasts and those who appreciate warm weather. The climate allows for year-round outdoor activities and a vibrant, active lifestyle.

9. Proximity to Naples and Fort Myers

Ave Maria is conveniently located near Naples and Fort Myers, two major cities in Southwest Florida. This proximity allows residents to enjoy the amenities, cultural attractions, and employment opportunities offered by these larger urban centers while still benefiting from the tranquility of a smaller town.

10. Growing Community

As a relatively new and developing town, Ave Maria offers the excitement and opportunities associated with a growing community. New businesses, services, and housing developments are continually emerging, providing residents with a dynamic and evolving living environment.

Cons of Living in Ave Maria, Florida

1. Limited Employment Opportunities

One of the main drawbacks of living in Ave Maria is the limited employment opportunities within the town itself. While there are jobs available in education, retail, and healthcare, many residents may need to commute to nearby cities like Naples or Fort Myers for work. This can be a disadvantage for those seeking employment within close proximity to their home.

2. High Temperatures and Humidity

While the warm climate can be a benefit, the high temperatures and humidity levels during the summer months can be challenging for some residents. The heat and humidity can make outdoor activities uncomfortable and may require the use of air conditioning to stay cool indoors.

3. Limited Nightlife and Entertainment

Ave Maria is a quiet, family-oriented community with limited nightlife and entertainment options. Residents seeking a vibrant social scene with bars, nightclubs, and diverse cultural activities may need to travel to nearby cities. This limited entertainment scene may not appeal to younger individuals or those who enjoy a bustling nightlife.

4. Potential for Isolation

Due to its relatively remote location, some residents may feel isolated in Ave Maria. The town’s distance from larger urban centers can make it challenging to access certain amenities and services. Additionally, the town’s strong faith-based identity may not appeal to everyone, potentially leading to feelings of exclusion for those with different beliefs or lifestyles.

5. Higher Cost of Living

The cost of living in Ave Maria can be higher than in other parts of Florida, particularly in terms of housing and property taxes. While the town offers many amenities and a high quality of life, the associated costs may be a consideration for potential residents, particularly those on a tight budget.

6. Limited Healthcare Facilities

While Ave Maria has some healthcare services, the options within the town are limited compared to larger cities. Residents may need to travel to Naples or Fort Myers for specialized medical care or more comprehensive healthcare services. This can be inconvenient, especially for individuals with chronic health conditions or specialized medical needs.

7. Development and Construction

As a growing community, Ave Maria is constantly undergoing development and construction. While this growth brings new amenities and services, it can also lead to noise, traffic, and temporary disruptions. Potential residents should be prepared for the ongoing development and the associated inconveniences.

8. Seasonal Tourism

The influx of tourists and seasonal residents, known as “snowbirds,” can lead to crowded public spaces and increased traffic during the winter months. While tourism boosts the local economy, the seasonal population surge can sometimes disrupt the peacefulness and routine of year-round residents.

9. Homogeneity

Ave Maria’s strong Catholic identity can lead to a more homogeneous population, which may lack the diversity found in other communities. This homogeneity can affect the variety of perspectives and experiences available to residents, potentially limiting the cultural and social richness of the community.

10. Transportation and Commute

Public transportation options in Ave Maria are limited, making it necessary for most residents to own a car. This can be a disadvantage for those who prefer using public transit or for individuals who do not drive. The need for a personal vehicle can also contribute to transportation costs and traffic congestion during peak hours.


Living in Ave Maria, Florida, offers a unique blend of modern amenities, strong community ties, and a faith-based environment. The town’s beautiful surroundings, excellent educational opportunities, and low crime rate make it an attractive option for families, retirees, and individuals seeking a supportive and engaging community. However, potential residents must also consider the challenges associated with living in Ave Maria, such as limited employment opportunities, high temperatures and humidity, and the town’s remote location.

The decision to move to Ave Maria should be made with careful consideration of both the pros and cons. By understanding the advantages and challenges of living in this unique community, potential residents can make an informed choice that aligns with their lifestyle and priorities. Whether you are drawn to Ave Maria’s strong sense of community, modern amenities, or faith-based environment, this town offers a distinctive living experience for those who are well-informed and prepared for the journey.

Leave a Comment